≡ Menu

≡ Menu

Exam vs. No Exam Life Insurance… Which is better?

⚖️

Speed vs. Savings—Know the Tradeoff

One Isn’t Always Better

No-exam life insurance approves faster without medical tests but typically costs more. Exam-required policies cost less but involve bloodwork, medical history, and longer underwriting. Neither is universally “better”—the right choice depends on your health, timeline, and financial priorities.
  • No-Exam Policies: Fast approval (24-48 hours) but higher premiums
  • Exam-Required Policies: Lower ongoing costs but 2-4 week approval process
  • Healthy individuals: Exams typically result in better rates
  • Time-sensitive situations: No-exam policies solve urgent needs
“For most healthy people seeking permanent coverage, enduring an exam saves thousands over the policy’s lifetime. For those in urgent situations or with health barriers, no-exam policies solve a real problem.” — InsuranceBrokers USA – Management Team

This comparison cuts through marketing language to help you understand the genuine tradeoffs between convenience and cost. The decision hinges on three factors: your current health, how urgently you need coverage, and your ability to work through the underwriting process. Understanding these distinctions prevents choosing a policy that doesn’t match your actual situation.

Approval Speed (No-Exam)

24-48 Hours
Fastest possible coverage

Approval Speed (Exam)

2-4 Weeks
Includes medical testing and review

Cost Difference (Healthy)

15-30%
Exam policies typically cost less

10-Year Cost (No-Exam)

$6,000-8,000
On $50/month base premium

What Are the Options?

Two Different Underwriting Approaches

Every life insurance policy requires underwriting—the process of evaluating your risk before the company commits to coverage. The underwriting method determines how much information the company collects and how thoroughly it investigates. No-exam policies collect minimal health information (usually through a phone interview); exam-required policies collect extensive information, including medical exams, laboratory tests, and a detailed health history review. This fundamental difference creates the cost and speed tradeoff you face.

Why the Difference Matters

With limited health information, insurance companies can’t accurately assess your risk, so they charge higher rates to protect themselves. If you’re healthy but they don’t know it (because no exam occurred), they charge the rate of someone with unknown health. With detailed exam results and health data, companies can precisely assess your risk and charge accordingly. A healthy person with exam results pays less; an unhealthy person with exam results pays more. This is where the real tradeoff emerges: speed and convenience versus accurate pricing.

No-Exam Life Insurance Explained

Application Process

You complete a simple phone or online application, answering basic health questions: Do you smoke? Any serious health conditions? Current medications? Any recent hospitalizations? These questions take 10-15 minutes. You don’t undergo bloodwork, don’t visit a lab, don’t provide medical records. The company issues approval within 24-48 hours based solely on your answers. This speed isthe  no-exam insurance’s primary appeal.

How They Protect Themselves

Insurance companies offering no-exam policies protect themselves through: (1) higher base rates to account for unknown health risk, (2) lower coverage maximums (often $500,000-$1M capped), (3) stricter underwriting based on data they DO have access to (prescription drug databases, medical records if you authorize), and (4) contestability periods where they can investigate after issuing the policy. Some no-exam policies include graded benefits where reduced payouts apply if you die in the first 2-3 years, further protecting the insurer.

When They Verify Health Information

After approving your policy, the company may conduct medical record reviews or prescription database checks. If they discover you lied (saying you don’t have diabetes when you do), they can rescind the policy (cancel it and deny claims) or adjust your rates. This is the contestability period—typically 2 years from the policy issue. Always be truthful on applications; misrepresentations discovered during underwriting create serious problems.

Who Should Consider No-Exam Policies

No-exam policies make sense if you need coverage urgently (death in the family, sudden financial responsibility), can’t wait 2-4 weeks for underwriting, or truly believe you’ll be rated higher by an insurance company for unknown reasons. Genuinely healthy people with straightforward health profiles might still choose no-exam if speed matters more than cost savings.

Exam-Required Life Insurance Explained

Application and Underwriting Process

You complete a detailed application with a comprehensive health history. The company requests authorization to gather medical records from your doctors. You schedule a medical exam—either at home (for most applicants) or at a lab. The exam includes height, weight, blood pressure, bloodwork (complete blood count and chemistry panel), and sometimes urine tests. For larger coverage amounts or applicants over 60, additional testing may be required. The process takes 2-4 weeks from application to approval decision.

What They Discover and How It Affects Rates

Exam results provide precise health data: cholesterol levels, blood pressure, smoking markers, liver and kidney function, and glucose levels. These results determine your health rating—Preferred Plus (best rates), Preferred, Standard, or Substandard (highest rates), depending on results. A healthy 40-year-old might get Preferred Plus rates; the same person showing high cholesterol and prediabetes might get Standard rates 30-40% higher. A 50-year-old with discovered heart disease might decline entirely.

Why You Get Better Rates If Healthy

Companies know exactly what health condition they’re accepting. If exam results show you’re genuinely healthy—normal blood pressure, excellent cholesterol, no indicators of disease—they charge lower rates because they’ve verified your low risk. A healthy person paying for a no-exam policy subsidizes the cost because the company assumes moderate risk. Once the exam confirms health, the subsidy disappears and rates drop accordingly.

No Medical Exam Coverage Limits

Some life insurance companies offer no-exam coverage up to a certain limit ($250,000-$500,000), then require exams for higher coverage amounts. This is a hybrid approach—quick approval for moderate coverage, but exams are needed if you want substantial protection. This becomes relevant if you need $1M+ coverage; exam requirements kick in above a certain threshold.

Real Cost Comparison Over Time

Example Scenario: 35-Year-Old Healthy Non-Smoker Seeking $500,000 Term Insurance

  • No-Exam Policy Rate: $50/month
  • Exam-Required Policy Rate: $38/month (24% less)

10-Year Comparison:

  • No-Exam: $50 × 120 months = $6,000 total
  • Exam: $38 × 120 months = $4,560 total
  • Savings with Exam: $1,440

20-Year Comparison:

  • No-Exam: $50 × 240 months = $12,000 total
  • Exam: $38 × 240 months = $9,120 total
  • Savings with Exam: $2,880
  • Time Investment: 2-4 weeks for the exam, plus 2-3 hours of your time

When the Breakeven Point Occurs

In the scenario above, you recover the time and effort investment in roughly 18-24 months. After two years of ownership, you’re saving money by having chosen the exam-required policy. This assumes you actually qualify for lower rates based on health exam results. The longer you keep the policy, the more valuable the exam becomes.

When No-Exam Makes Financial Sense

No-exam policies make financial sense if you only need coverage for a short period (1-2 years), believe exam results will worsen your rating rather than improve it, or value speed so much you’re willing to pay a premium for it. For someone truly confident they’re healthy but unwilling to prove it, no-exam policies might be cheaper than the alternative—declining insurance altogether and facing risk without protection.

When to Choose Each Option

Choose No-Exam If:

You need coverage immediately. Death in the family requires coverage this week, not four weeks from now.

You have health conditions, an exam might worsen your rating on. If borderline conditions (high cholesterol, pre-diabetes, high blood pressure) exist that might trigger higher rates or denial, the no-exam eliminates this risk.

You’re planning to keep coverage for only 1-2 years. If you won’t own the policy long enough for exam savings to accumulate, no-exam’s simplicity makes sense.

You have medical anxiety about exams. If undergoing medical exams creates genuine stress, no-exam eliminates that burden.

Choose Exam-Required If:

You’re healthy with no significant health issues. Clean health history and normal exam results translate to better rates than no-exam policies charge.

You’re purchasing long-term coverage. Planning to keep the policy 10-20+ years means exam savings compound substantially.

You want the lowest possible rates. Exams ensure you get the best rating your health qualifies for.

You need substantial coverage ($750,000+). Higher coverage amounts almost always require exams; you’re choosing between exam-required or no coverage at that level.

You’re comfortable with standard underwriting processes. You don’t mind the 2-4 week timeline or exam requirements.

Understanding the Underwriting Process

What Exams Typically Include:

  • Basic Vital Signs: Height, weight, blood pressure, pulse. These establish baseline health and identify obvious concerns (obesity, high blood pressure).
  • Laboratory Tests: Blood draw testing for cholesterol, glucose, liver function, kidney function, and complete blood count. Urine tests check for kidney disease, diabetes markers, and drug use. These reveal conditions that aren’t apparent from appearance or symptoms.
  • Additional Tests (Sometimes): For older applicants or very large coverage amounts, EKG (heart), stress tests, or specialist exams might be required. These become relevant for applicants over 60 or requesting $1M+ coverage.

How Long Different Steps Take:

  • Application to Exam Scheduling: 3-7 days. The company reviews your application, then coordinates scheduling with you.
  • Exam (if in-home): 30-45 minutes. The paramedic visits your home, conducts tests, and collects samples.
  • Lab Processing: 5-10 days. Samples are analyzed and results reported.
  • Medical Records Review: 5-7 days. The company requests records from your doctors, receives them, and reviews them for consistency.
  • Final Underwriting Decision: 3-5 days. The underwriter reviews all information and issues approval, denial, or conditional approval.

Total Timeline: 2-4 weeks from application to approval decision.

What Exams Don’t Reveal (and Why)

Exams test current health, not future health. Someone with normal exam results today could develop cancer next year. This is why insurance companies use actuarial data and demographics alongside exam results—they understand that exams capture current status, not predict future outcomes. Additionally, exams don’t detect conditions that someone hides or doesn’t know about. If you have undiagnosed high blood pressure but have never been checked, it won’t appear in exam results.

Contestability Period

All life insurance policies include a contestability period (typically 2 years) where the insurance company can investigate and potentially rescind the policy if material misrepresentations are discovered. If you answered “no” to diabetes on your application but doctors’ records show you have it, the company can deny claims during this period. After contestability expires, the company generally can’t deny claims for pre-existing conditions (with some exceptions). This is why truthfulness on applications matters critically.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the medical exam disqualify me?

Direct answer: Possibly, but more likely you’ll receive approval at a higher rate than expected.

Exam results that trigger rate increases are common; complete denials are less common. If you have serious health conditions (advanced cancer, severe heart disease), the company might decline. If you have controlled conditions or minor health issues, approval usually happens, just at a higher rate than preferred health. Before submitting an application, assess whether you’re confident enough to undergo underwriting.

Does medical exam information get used against me outside of life insurance application?

Direct answer: No. Medical exam results are confidential and used only for underwriting purposes.

Life insurance companies don’t share exam results with health insurers, employers, or other entities. The results are protected and used solely for the insurance underwriting decision. Your privacy is legally protected through medical confidentiality laws. This is one reason people sometimes choose exam-required policies—they can discover health issues requiring attention without those results affecting employment, other insurance, or other aspects of life.

Can I switch from no-exam to exam-required if the rates aren’t good enough?

Direct answer: Usually not directly, but you can apply for new coverage separately.

Once you accept a no-exam policy, you can’t retroactively require an exam with that same policy to get better rates. However, you can apply for a separate exam-required policy and compare both. If exam results are better, you’d drop the no-exam policy and keep the exam-required policy. This results in a brief overlap of two policies, but gives you options if no-exam rates prove disappointing.

Do I have to take an exam for higher coverage amounts?

Direct answer: Usually yes. Most companies have no-exam limits above which exams become mandatory.

Typical limits range from $250,000-$500,000 without an exam. Requesting $750,000 or $1M typically requires underwriting, including exams. This is the company protecting itself—large death benefits justify a thorough investigation. Some companies offer no-exam up to $1M for very healthy applicants, but most have lower thresholds.

What if I lie on my application?

Direct answer: During the contestability period, it can result in claim denial. After contestability, you’re generally protected.

If you misrepresent health information (saying you don’t smoke when you do, or omitting health conditions) and the company discovers the lie within 2 years, they can deny death benefits and cancel the policy. After contestability expires, they generally can’t deny based on pre-existing conditions or misrepresentations—protection kicks in. However, fraud can result in criminal liability. Always answer truthfully; the consequences of dishonesty aren’t worth the short-term premium savings.

Can I choose which company offers better rates—exam or no-exam?

Direct answer: Yes. Shop both options and compare actual rates before deciding.

Get quotes from multiple carriers for both exam-required and no-exam policies. Company A might offer excellent no-exam rates; Company B might offer excellent exam-based rates. Compare final costs, not just the underwriting approach. The better value depends on your specific situation and each company’s pricing.

Ready to Find Your Best Coverage Option?

Get quotes for both exam-required and no-exam policies. Compare actual rates and timelines specific to your situation.

Call Now: 888-211-6171

Licensed agents can provide quotes for both underwriting approaches and help you understand which option makes sense for your needs, health, and timeline.

Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or insurance advice. Specific rates, underwriting requirements, and policy terms vary significantly by insurance company, applicant age, health, coverage amount, and location. No-exam policies and exam-required policies may have different coverage limits, waiting periods, and restrictions. All information reflects 2025 industry standards. Consult with a licensed insurance professional to discuss which underwriting approach best matches your specific circumstances, health profile, and coverage needs.

 

0 comments… add one

Leave a Comment