When traditional life insurance companies keep saying “no,” it’s natural to feel frustrated and wonder if any coverage exists for people with serious health conditions. Perhaps you’ve been declined multiple times, or maybe you’re avoiding the application process entirely because you know your medical history will be a barrier. In some situations, this may be preventable; at other times, clients will need to seek out a guaranteed issue life insurance policy as a last resort.
Not the silver bullet many hope for, guaranteed issue life insurance policies can provide a legitimate path to coverage when health problems or lifestyle choices have closed other doors. The challenge lies in understanding exactly what you’re buying and whether the trade-offs make financial sense for your specific needs.
In this guide, we will examine guaranteed issue life insurance from every angle—costs, benefits, limitations, and alternatives. You’ll learn when these policies deliver genuine value and when they might drain your savings without providing meaningful protection. Most importantly, you’ll discover how to make an informed decision that serves your family’s actual needs.
By the Insurance Brokers USA Team
The Insurance Brokers USA Team consists of licensed insurance professionals with extensive experience helping clients with complex health conditions find appropriate coverage. Our agents have worked with hundreds of individuals facing traditional life insurance challenges, specializing in guaranteed issue solutions when medical underwriting isn’t an option.
What Is Guaranteed Issue Life Insurance Really?
This accessibility comes with significant trade-offs. Coverage amounts are typically limited to $5,000-$25,000, premiums are substantially higher than traditional life insurance, and waiting periods apply before full benefits become available. These policies function more like expensive final expense coverage than comprehensive life insurance protection.
Bottom Line
Guaranteed issue policies solve one specific problem—providing some life insurance when traditional coverage is impossible—but they’re expensive, limited, and often not the best financial choice even for people with health issues.
Understanding what guaranteed issue insurance actually provides versus what marketing materials suggest can help you make a more informed decision about whether it fits your situation and budget.
How Does the Waiting Period Actually Work?
Key insight: The waiting period (graded death benefit) is the most crucial feature to understand, as it significantly limits coverage during the first 2-3 years when many purchasers are most likely to pass away.
Guaranteed issue policies include two types of coverage from day one:
- Accidental death benefit: Full death benefit if you die in an accident
- Return of premium: If you die from natural causes during the waiting period, beneficiaries receive premiums paid plus typically 10% interest
The full death benefit only applies after the waiting period expires (usually 24-36 months) for deaths from natural causes like illness, disease, or age-related conditions.
“Based on industry studies of guaranteed issue claims data, approximately 40% of policyholders pass away from natural causes within the first three years. This means a significant portion of purchasers never receive the full death benefit they thought they were buying.”
– Insurance Brokers USA Claims Analysis Team
Example: $10,000 Policy Death Benefits by Timing
| Death Timing | Cause: Accident | Cause: Natural | Premiums Paid* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 6 | $10,000 | $660 | $600 |
| Month 18 | $10,000 | $1,980 | $1,800 |
| Month 30+ | $10,000 | $10,000 | $3,000 |
*Assumes $100/month premium
This structure means that many purchasers effectively pay high premiums for what amounts to a premium savings account with modest interest during the period when they’re most likely to need the coverage.
Who Should Actually Consider This Coverage?
Key insight: Guaranteed issue life insurance makes financial sense for a narrow group of people who have exhausted other options and need final expense coverage, but it’s often oversold to people who have better alternatives.
Good Candidates (Limited Circumstances):
- Ages 60+ with serious health conditions: Terminal illness, advanced heart disease, or conditions that guarantee traditional coverage denial
- Multiple previous denials: People who have been declined by several insurers after medical underwriting
- Specific final expense needs: Those who need exactly $5,000-$25,000 for funeral costs and have no other means to provide this amount
- Cannot obtain group coverage: People without access to employer or association life insurance
Poor Candidates (Better Options Exist):
- Anyone under 50: Traditional coverage is almost always more cost-effective
- People with mild health conditions, such as Diabetes, high blood pressure, or depression, often qualify for traditional coverage at better rates
- Those needing large amounts: The $25,000 maximum rarely provides meaningful income replacement
- People with existing savings: Self-insuring final expenses may be more cost-effective than guaranteed issue premiums
“We often see people purchase guaranteed issue policies when simplified issue or even traditional coverage would have been available at much better rates. The ‘no questions asked’ marketing appeals to people who assume they can’t qualify for anything else, but that assumption is frequently wrong.”
– Insurance Brokers USA Team
Key Takeaways
- Always explore traditional and simplified issue options first
- Guaranteed issue should be a last resort, not a first choice
- Consider whether self-funding final expenses might be more cost-effective
- Don’t assume you can’t qualify for traditional coverage without trying
What Are the Real Costs Involved?
Key insight: Guaranteed issue life insurance premiums are typically 3-5 times higher than traditional coverage, and when you factor in the waiting period limitations, the effective cost per dollar of actual coverage becomes extremely high.
The high premiums reflect the adverse selection inherent in guaranteed issue pools—insurers know they’re covering people who couldn’t qualify elsewhere, so they price accordingly. Understanding the true cost requires looking beyond monthly premiums to examine total cost over time versus actual benefits received.
Real-World Premium Comparison ($10,000 Coverage)
| Age/Gender | Guaranteed Issue | Traditional (Healthy) | 10-Year Cost Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65-year-old male | $95/month | $32/month | $7,560 more |
| 70-year-old female | $78/month | $26/month | $6,240 more |
| 75-year-old male | $142/month | $58/month | $10,080 more |
Hidden Cost Factors:
- Opportunity cost: Money spent on high premiums could be invested for final expenses instead
- Inflation impact: Fixed coverage amounts lose purchasing power over time
- Premium increases: Some policies allow premium increases despite marketing claims of “level” premiums
- Lapse risk: High premiums increase the likelihood of policy cancellation
“When we run the numbers for clients, many are shocked to discover that putting the guaranteed issue premium amount into a simple savings account often provides more money for final expenses within 5-7 years, even with minimal interest rates. The only problem is, few people will actually do this.”
– Insurance Brokers USA Financial Analysis Team
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis:
For a guaranteed issue to make financial sense, you typically need to:
- Survive the waiting period to access full benefits
- Live long enough that total premiums paid don’t exceed the death benefit
- Have no better alternatives for funding final expenses
- Value the peace of mind enough to justify the premium cost
Bottom Line
Guaranteed issue premiums can often cost more over 10-15 years than the death benefit provides. It’s expensive coverage that should only be purchased when no alternatives exist and immediate family protection is essential.
What Are the Honest Benefits and Limitations?
Key insight: While guaranteed issue policies do provide valuable access to coverage for people who truly have no other options, the limitations significantly outweigh the benefits for most potential purchasers.
Genuine Benefits:
- Accessibility: Coverage available when health conditions prevent traditional approval
- Immediate accidental death protection: Full benefit from day one for accidental deaths
- Simple application: No medical exams, records, or complex underwriting
- Fast approval: Policies are typically issued within 24-48 hours
- Premium protection: Some protection against total loss if you die during the waiting period
Significant Limitations:
- Extremely high premiums: Often 300-500% higher than traditional coverage
- Low coverage limits: Maximum $25,000 provides minimal financial protection
- Waiting periods: Limited benefits for 2-3 years when coverage is most likely needed
- No cash value: No living benefits or borrowing opportunities
- No medical underwriting benefits: Cannot qualify for better rates even if health improves
Guaranteed Issue vs. Alternative Options
| Option | Requirements | Typical Cost | Coverage Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed Issue | Age 50-85 only | Very High | $5K-$25K |
| Simplified Issue | Health questions only | High | $25K-$300K |
| Traditional Term | Full underwriting | Low-Moderate | $100K-$5M+ |
| Self-Insurance | Discipline to save | Opportunity cost | Unlimited |
Key Takeaways
- Benefits are primarily about access, not value or comprehensive protection
- High costs and low limits make guaranteed issue unsuitable for most insurance needs
- Alternative options should always be explored before choosing guaranteed issue
- The waiting period significantly reduces the practical value of coverage
How Do You Choose the Right Policy?
Key insight: Choosing a guaranteed issue policy requires focusing on carrier financial strength, waiting period length, and total cost over time rather than just monthly premiums, since all policies provide similar basic coverage.
Essential Selection Criteria:
1. Carrier Financial Stability (Most Important)
Since you may pay premiums for many years before benefits are needed, choose insurers with A.M. Best ratings of A- or higher. A financially weak insurer could fail before paying your claim.
2. Waiting Period Length
Two-year waiting periods are significantly better than three-year periods. This difference could mean thousands of dollars to your beneficiaries if you pass away in year three.
3. Total Cost Analysis
Compare total premiums over 10-15 years, not just monthly costs. Some policies with higher monthly premiums may have better long-term value due to slower premium increases.
4. Premium Stability
Look for policies with guaranteed level premiums versus those that allow increases. Premium increases can make policies unaffordable over time.
“The most expensive mistake we see is people choosing guaranteed issue policies based solely on the lowest monthly premium. A policy that costs $15 less per month but has a three-year waiting period instead of two years could cost beneficiaries the entire death benefit if death occurs in year three.”
– Insurance Brokers USA Policy Analysis Team
Before You Buy: Alternative Exploration Checklist
- Simplified issue policies: Limited health questions but better rates
- Group coverage through employers or associations
- Traditional life insurance with health conditions: Many conditions still qualify
- Accidental death and dismemberment policies: Lower cost for accident-only coverage
- Self-funding through savings: May provide better returns over time
Coverage Amount Considerations:
Calculate actual final expense needs rather than buying maximum available coverage:
- Average funeral costs in your area ($7,000-$15,000)
- Outstanding medical bills and small debts
- Immediate cash needs for family
- Estate settlement costs
Bottom Line
Focus on carrier strength and waiting period length over premium costs. The cheapest monthly premium often delivers the worst overall value when you need the coverage most.
Which Companies Offer the Best Value?
Key insight: The “best” guaranteed issue insurer balances competitive pricing with strong financial ratings and favorable policy terms, though no guaranteed issue policy offers exceptional value compared to traditional alternatives.
Top Guaranteed Issue Insurers (2025 Analysis)
AIG (American General Life)
Financial Rating: A (Excellent) | Waiting Period: 2 years | Max Coverage: $25,000
Strengths: Strong financial stability, competitive pricing, broad state availability, and reliable claims paying
Considerations: Limited coverage amounts, standard waiting period
Mutual of Omaha
Financial Rating: A+ (Superior) | Waiting Period: 2 years | Max Coverage: $40,000
Strengths: Highest financial ratings, higher coverage limits, established reputation
Considerations: Premium costs slightly above average
Great Western Insurance
Financial Rating: A- (Excellent) | Waiting Period: 2 years | Max Coverage: $25,000
Strengths: Competitive premium pricing, lower minimum coverage amounts, simple application process
Considerations: Limited to smaller coverage amounts, fewer policy features
Gerber Life Insurance
Financial Rating: A+ (Superior) | Waiting Period: 2 years | Max Coverage: $25,000
Strengths: Strong financial foundation, straightforward policy terms, reliable claims processing
Considerations: Limited coverage amounts, premium costs above average
Evaluation Criteria Used:
- Financial strength ratings: Only companies rated A- or higher included
- Claims-paying history: Consistent record of honoring policy benefits
- Premium competitiveness: Pricing within a reasonable range of market averages
- Policy terms: Two-year waiting periods and stable premium structures
- State availability: Coverage offered in the majority of U.S. states
“When evaluating guaranteed issue carriers, financial strength should be your top priority. You may pay premiums for 10-20 years before benefits are needed, so choosing a financially stable insurer is crucial. A company that saves you $10 per month but fails financially provides no value.”
– Insurance Brokers USA Carrier Analysis Team
Key Takeaways
- All top carriers offer similar basic benefits with 2-year waiting periods
- Financial strength ratings are more important than small premium differences
- Maximum coverage limits vary significantly between carriers
- State availability can limit your carrier options
Frequently Asked Questions
Direct answer: No, guaranteed issue life insurance is rarely a good financial deal due to high premiums and limited coverage, but it can provide valuable access to coverage when no other options exist.
The high cost reflects the fact that insurers are covering people who couldn’t qualify elsewhere. For most people, exploring traditional or simplified issue coverage first will provide much better value. Guaranteed issue should only be considered when health conditions make other coverage impossible.
Direct answer: If you die from natural causes during the waiting period, your beneficiaries typically receive only the premiums you paid plus 10% interest, not the full death benefit.
However, if death results from an accident, the full death benefit is paid immediately from day one. This limited coverage during the waiting period is why guaranteed issue policies provide minimal value for people who are likely to pass away from existing health conditions within 2-3 years.
Direct answer: You can only be denied if you don’t meet basic eligibility requirements: typically being ages 50-85, a U.S. citizen, and residing in a state where the policy is offered.
Unlike traditional life insurance, guaranteed issue policies cannot deny coverage based on health conditions, medical history, lifestyle factors, or occupation. The guarantee applies to anyone meeting the basic eligibility criteria.
Direct answer: Absolutely not. Healthy individuals should pursue traditional life insurance, which provides much better value with lower premiums and higher coverage limits.
Guaranteed issue insurance is specifically designed for people who cannot qualify for traditional coverage due to serious health conditions. If you’re healthy enough to pass medical underwriting, traditional policies will cost significantly less and provide more comprehensive protection.
Direct answer: Buy only what you need for final expenses—typically $10,000-$15,000 for funeral costs and immediate bills—as guaranteed issue premiums make larger amounts extremely expensive over time.
Calculate your actual final expense needs rather than buying the maximum available. Consider funeral costs in your area, outstanding medical bills, small debts, and immediate family cash needs. Avoid over-insuring, as the high premiums can drain resources that could be used more effectively.
Direct answer: Alternatives include simplified issue life insurance, group coverage through employers, accidental death policies, pre-need funeral insurance, and self-funding through savings accounts.
Many people assume guaranteed issue is their only option when alternatives exist. Simplified issue policies require answering health questions but no medical exam, often providing better rates. Group life insurance through employers or associations typically doesn’t require medical underwriting and costs less than guaranteed issue coverage.
Important Disclaimer
This article provides general information about guaranteed issue life insurance and should not be considered personalized insurance advice. Policy terms, pricing, and availability vary significantly between carriers and states. Insurance decisions should be made in consultation with qualified insurance professionals who can evaluate your specific situation and needs. Always review policy documents carefully and explore all available alternatives before purchasing guaranteed issue coverage.
Need Help Evaluating Your Life Insurance Options?
Our experienced team specializes in helping clients explore all available life insurance options, including guaranteed issue policies when appropriate. We provide honest assessments about whether guaranteed issue coverage makes sense for your situation or if better alternatives exist.
Why Choose Insurance Brokers USA:
- Comprehensive evaluation of traditional, simplified, and guaranteed issue options
- Access to multiple top-rated carriers for comparison shopping
- Honest guidance about cost-effectiveness and alternatives
- No-cost consultation with experienced insurance professionals
Call us today for an honest evaluation: 888-211-6171
Licensed insurance professionals available Monday-Friday, 8 AM – 6 PM EST. We’ll help you determine if guaranteed issue coverage is right for your situation or if better options exist.
Related Resources
Hello,
I provide support for my 2 elder sisters- Pam is 73 and in a care facility in NJ, Deb is 71 in senior housing in MA and our family burial plot is in NY. I want to take out a small immediate full payout policy on each so I can have the resources to pay for cremation and transit of items to me for a later trip home with them to the family plot if things happen during COVID times and I cannot travel now. I would appreciate information on this option
Many thanks
Doe
Doe,
It sounds like you are looking to purchase a life insurance policy that each of your sisters would need to be able to “medically qualify” for. For this reason, it would be best for you to give us a call so that we can learn a little bit more about each one of your sister’s medical “status” before we make any assumptions about what they may or may not be able to qualify for.
Thanks,
InsuranceBrokersUSA.